Background: An efficacy evaluation of the AutoAnthro system to measure
child (0–59 months) anthropometry in USA found three-dimensional imaging
performed as well as gold-standard manual measurements for biological
plausibility and precision. Objectives: Conduct an effectiveness
evaluation of the accuracy of the AutoAnthro system to measure 0–59 months
child anthropometry in population-based surveys and surveillance systems
in households in Guatemala and Kenya, and in hospitals in China. Methods:
The evaluation was done using health or nutrition surveillance system
platforms among 600 children 0–59 months (Guatemala, Kenya) and 300
children 0-23 months (China). Field team anthropometrists and
their assistants collected from each child manual and scan anthropometric
measurements including length/height, mid-upper arm circumference (MUAC),
and head circumference (HC, China only). An anthropometry expert
and assistant later collected both manual and scan anthropometric
measurements on the same child. The expert manual measurements
were considered the standard compared to field team scans. Results:
Overall, in Guatemala, Kenya and China, respectively, for inter-rater
accuracy, average bias for length/height was -0.3 cm, -1.9 cm, -6.2 cm;
for MUAC was 0.9 cm, 1.2 cm, -0.8 cm; for HC was 2.4 cm; the
inter-technical error of measurement (TEM) for length/height was 2.8 cm,
3.4 cm, 5.5 cm; for MUAC was 1.1 cm, 1.5 cm, 1.0 cm; for HC was 2.8 cm.
For intra-rater precision, absolute mean difference and
intra-TEM were 0.1 cm for all countries for all manual measurements. For
scan, overall, absolute mean difference ranged for length/height 0.4-0.6
cm; MUAC 0.1-0.1 cm; HC was 0.4 cm. For intra-TEM, length/height was 0.5
cm in Guatemala and China, 0.7 cm in Kenya, and other measurements were
<0.3 cm. Conclusions: Understanding the factors that cause the many
poor scan results and how to correct them will be needed prior to using
this instrument in routine population-based survey and surveillance
systems. Details of the methods are provided in the article. A detailled codebook is included in the dataset.