This study examines the theological meanings that shape Christians’ selective church attendance, focusing on the widespread practice of attending watch night services on 31st December despite irregular participation in worship services throughout the year. Using a mixed-methods approach combining interviews and structured responses across churches in Accra, the study explores how believers interpret the spiritual significance of watch night worship. The findings show that attendance on 31st December is driven primarily by gratitude for survival, desire for divine protection, and hope for the coming year. Participants frame watch night services as liminal moments that require intentional engagement with God, rather than as substitutes for regular discipleship. While most respondents affirm the importance of regular church attendance, they also articulate a hierarchical understanding of sacred time in which certain moments carry greater spiritual urgency. The study argues that watch night attendance reflects lived theology and theological prioritisation rather than religious inconsistency, offering important implications for pastoral practice and church engagement strategies.