Preterm birth has ranked as one of the leading causes of neonatal mortality and morbidity in the world, with the most significant proportion of burden being based in Sub-Saharan Africa, with Nigeria bearing a disproportionate burden due to its population and the inability to overcome the health-system problem. In this study, observational evidence on determinants of preterm birth in Sub-Saharan Africa was systematically synthesised, with particular comparative evidence from Nigeria, using PRISMA-guided methods. Searches of major biomedical and African-based databases were conducted to identify studies published between 1990 and 2024 that examined associations between maternal sociodemographic, obstetric, clinical, and health-system factors and preterm birth (<37 weeks' gestation). These studies were synthesised through a narrative review and subjected to a structured comparative analysis. The prevalence of preterm birth was reported to be between 7.4 and 12.6 across the region, with hospital-based Nigerian cohorts at the top of this scale. Previous preterm birth (adjusted OR: 3.053) and multiple gestation (OR: 4.952) were the strongest predictors, indicating recurrent and biological effects. Maternal conditions, especially those involved with hypertensive (OR: 2.4–3.1) and anaemia (OR: 2.1–2.9), were strong and uniform across nations. Interestingly, health-system determinants were stronger in Nigeria, where the number of fewer than four antenatal care visits per woman nearly tripled the likelihood of preterm baby birth (OR: 2.53-3.6), which was higher in Nigeria than in the region. Poor maternal education and poverty as socioeconomic disadvantages predispose preterm birth by 30-90% in various environments. In general, preterm birth in Sub-Saharan Africa is an interaction of biological, social, and system-level factors, with Nigeria having more vulnerability due to modifiable health-governance failures and the necessity to create prevention-based maternal health policies.