Can Virtual Replace In-person Coaching? Experimental Evidence on Teacher Professional Development and Student Learning in South Africa
Domain:
educationRecord type:
paper
Creator:
JacBraJanNom
Publisher:
Res
Host:
Virtual communication holds the promise of enabling low-cost professional development at scale, but the benefits of in-person interaction might be difficult to replicate. We report on an experiment in South Africa comparing on-site with virtual coaching of public primary school teachers. After three years, on-site coaching improved students' English oral language and reading proficiency (0.31 and 0.13 SD, respectively). Virtual coaching had a smaller impact on English oral language proficiency (0.12 SD), no impact on English reading proficiency, and an unintended negative effect on home language literacy. Classroom observations show that on-site coaching improved teaching practices, and virtual coaching led to larger crowding-out of home language teaching time. Implementation and survey data suggest technology itself was not a barrier to implementation, but rather that in-person contact enabled more accountability and support.
Similar
Teacher Learning in Collaborative Professional Development: Changes in Teacher and Student PracticesTeacher professional development in Africa: A critical synthesis of African research evidenceTeacher trade unions, unionization of novice teachers, implications for professional development in South AfricaSocial Climate and Teacher Professional Development in TanzaniaEmbedding Inclusive Education in Teacher Professional Development in South Africa: Impact evaluation report on the Teaching for All projectExploring Blended Learning for Science Teacher Professional Development in an African Context